NJ Sutton and Extended Families

William B. McKinstry

M, b. circa 1840

William B. McKinstry|b. c 1840|p31.htm#i917|John McKinstry Jr.|b. c 1800\nd. b 1860|p28.htm#i845|Sarah Potter|b. c 1802|p30.htm#i910|Col. John McKinstry|b. c 1765\nd. bt 1840 - 1844|p28.htm#i834|Mary Sutton|b. 17 Nov 1771\nd. 19 May 1851|p28.htm#i832|Jonathan Potter||p30.htm#i911|Hannah Woolverton||p30.htm#i912|

William was born at New Jersey circa 1840. He was the son of John McKinstry Jr. and Sarah Potter.
William B. McKinstry appeared on the census of 23 July 1850 in the household of John McKinstry Jr. at Tewksbury Township, Hunterdon County, New Jersey.¹

Citations

[S975] 1850 Federal Census Hunterdon Co., NJ, Washington, District of Columbia, Roll: M432_453; Page: 266; Image: 529, line 18, dwelling 33, family 35.

Hannah L. McKinstry

F, b. circa 1843

Hannah L. McKinstry|b. c 1843|p31.htm#i918|John McKinstry Jr.|b. c 1800\nd. b 1860|p28.htm#i845|Sarah Potter|b. c 1802|p30.htm#i910|Col. John McKinstry|b. c 1765\nd. bt 1840 - 1844|p28.htm#i834|Mary Sutton|b. 17 Nov 1771\nd. 19 May 1851|p28.htm#i832|Jonathan Potter||p30.htm#i911|Hannah Woolverton||p30.htm#i912|

Hannah was born at New Jersey circa 1843. She was the daughter of John McKinstry Jr. and Sarah Potter.
Hannah L. McKinstry appeared on the census of 23 July 1850 in the household of John McKinstry Jr. at Tewksbury Township, Hunterdon County, New Jersey.¹

Citations

[S975] 1850 Federal Census Hunterdon Co., NJ, Washington, District of Columbia, Roll: M432_453; Page: 266; Image: 529, line 18, dwelling 33, family 35.

Andrew V. S. Melick

M, b. circa 1810

Andrew was born at New Jersey circa 1810. Birth date derived from 1850 NJ Census, Tewksbury Twp., Hunterdon Co.. He married Rachel McKinstry at New Jersey circa 1832.
Andrew V. S. Melick appeared on the census of June 1860 at Tewksbury Township, Hunterdon County, New Jersey.¹

Children of Andrew V. S. Melick and Rachel McKinstry

Sarah J. Melick b. c 1833
Anthony Melick b. c 1834
Andrew Melick b. c 1843

Citations

[S988] 1860 Federal Census Hunterdon Co., NJ, unknown location, page 41.

Sarah J. Melick

F, b. circa 1833

Sarah J. Melick|b. c 1833|p31.htm#i920|Andrew V. S. Melick|b. c 1810|p31.htm#i919|Rachel McKinstry|b. c 1812|p28.htm#i846|||||||Col. John McKinstry|b. c 1765\nd. bt 1840 - 1844|p28.htm#i834|Mary Sutton|b. 17 Nov 1771\nd. 19 May 1851|p28.htm#i832|

Sarah was born at New Jersey circa 1833. Birth date derived from 1850 NJ Census, Tewksbury Twp., Hunterdon Co.. She was the daughter of Andrew V. S. Melick and Rachel McKinstry.

Anthony Melick

M, b. circa 1834

Anthony Melick|b. c 1834|p31.htm#i921|Andrew V. S. Melick|b. c 1810|p31.htm#i919|Rachel McKinstry|b. c 1812|p28.htm#i846|||||||Col. John McKinstry|b. c 1765\nd. bt 1840 - 1844|p28.htm#i834|Mary Sutton|b. 17 Nov 1771\nd. 19 May 1851|p28.htm#i832|

Anthony was born at New Jersey circa 1834. Birth date derived from 1850 NJ Census, Tewksbury Twp., Hunterdon Co.. He was the son of Andrew V. S. Melick and Rachel McKinstry.
Anthony Melick appeared on the census of June 1860 in the household of Andrew V. S. Melick at Tewksbury Township, Hunterdon County, New Jersey.¹

Citations

[S988] 1860 Federal Census Hunterdon Co., NJ, unknown location, page 41.

Andrew Melick

M, b. circa 1843

Andrew Melick|b. c 1843|p31.htm#i922|Andrew V. S. Melick|b. c 1810|p31.htm#i919|Rachel McKinstry|b. c 1812|p28.htm#i846|||||||Col. John McKinstry|b. c 1765\nd. bt 1840 - 1844|p28.htm#i834|Mary Sutton|b. 17 Nov 1771\nd. 19 May 1851|p28.htm#i832|

Andrew was born at New Jersey circa 1843. Birth date derived from 1850 NJ Census, Tewksbury Twp., Hunterdon Co.. He was the son of Andrew V. S. Melick and Rachel McKinstry.
Andrew Melick appeared on the census of June 1860 in the household of Andrew V. S. Melick at Tewksbury Township, Hunterdon County, New Jersey.¹

Citations

[S988] 1860 Federal Census Hunterdon Co., NJ, unknown location, page 41.

Aaron H. McKinstry

Aaron H. McKinstry||p31.htm#i923|Alexander McKinstry|b. c 1814\nd. 17 Dec 1839|p28.htm#i847||||Col. John McKinstry|b. c 1765\nd. bt 1840 - 1844|p28.htm#i834|Mary Sutton|b. 17 Nov 1771\nd. 19 May 1851|p28.htm#i832|||||||

Aaron H. McKinstry was the son of Alexander McKinstry.

Eliza Jane McKinstry

Eliza Jane McKinstry||p31.htm#i924|Alexander McKinstry|b. c 1814\nd. 17 Dec 1839|p28.htm#i847||||Col. John McKinstry|b. c 1765\nd. bt 1840 - 1844|p28.htm#i834|Mary Sutton|b. 17 Nov 1771\nd. 19 May 1851|p28.htm#i832|||||||

Eliza Jane McKinstry was the daughter of Alexander McKinstry.

Peter Sutton

M, b. circa 1789, d. 10 February 1876

Peter Sutton|b. c 1789\nd. 10 Feb 1876|p31.htm#i925|Aaron Sutton|b. bt 1760 - 1770\nd. c 1844|p3.htm#i83|Mary Schuyler|b. bt 1760 - 1770\nd. b 1840|p17.htm#i495|John Sutton|b. c 1738\nd. 21 Nov 1822|p3.htm#i71|Elizabeth Aubel|b. c 1743\nd. 15 Nov 1825|p3.htm#i72|Philip Schuyler||p16.htm#i473|Ann Anderson||p16.htm#i474|

Peter Sutton was born circa 1789 at New Jersey.¹ He was the son of Aaron Sutton and Mary Schuyler. He married Elizabeth Tiger circa 1807 at New Jersey. He died on 10 February 1876 at Cokesbury, Tewksbury Township, Hunterdon County, New Jersey. Death announcements notes death as 31 Jan 1876.^2,3
Peter Sutton appeared on the census of 1830 at Tewksbury Township, Hunterdon County, New Jersey. Census notes:

1M 5-10
1M 40-50
2F 5-10
1F 10-15
1F 15-20
1F 40-50.⁴ He appeared on the census of 1840 at Hunterdon County, New Jersey. Census notes:

1M 10-15
1M 50-60
1F 5-10
1F 10-15
1F 50-60.⁵ He appeared on the census of 12 August 1850 at Tewksbury Township, Hunterdon County, New Jersey.⁶ He appeared on the census of 30 July 1860 at Clinton Township, Hunterdon County, New Jersey. Also noted with family is Peter Tiger, 16 (b. ca 1846).⁷ He appeared on the census of 24 August 1870 at Clinton Township, Hunterdon County, New Jersey. Peter and Elizabeth are noted as unable to read or write.⁸

Children of Peter Sutton and Elizabeth Tiger

? Sutton b. bt 1810 - 1815
? Sutton b. bt 1815 - 1820
Catharine Sutton b. c 1823
Jeremiah C. Sutton b. c 1825, d. 17 Aug 1856
Malinda Sutton b. c 1827
? Sutton b. bt 1830 - 1835

Citations

[S975] 1850 Federal Census Hunterdon Co., NJ, Washington, District of Columbia, page 284A, line 25.
[S983] NJ Deaths: Deaths 1875-76, Microfilm Vol. BB, Reel 52, p. 31.
[S1165] Hunterdon County Democrat, 15 Feb 1876, Vol. 38, No. 24, Whole No. 1950, At Cokesbury, Jan. 31, Peter Sutton, aged 86 years.
[S1059] 1830 Federal Census Hunterdon Co., NJ, Washington, District of Columbia, Census notes the following:

1 male - 5-10
1 male - 40-50
2 females - 5-10
1 female - 10-15
1 female - 15-20
1 female - 40-50.
[S989] 1840 Federal Census Hunterdon Co., NJ, Washington, District of Columbia, Roll 253; Page: 244.
[S975] 1850 Federal Census Hunterdon Co., NJ, Washington, District of Columbia, Microfilm Roll: M432_453, page 284A, line 25.
[S988] 1860 Federal Census Hunterdon Co., NJ, unknown location, Microfilm M653-696, p. 696, line 30. Census notes: Peter is 71, Elizabeth 72, and Catherine 39.
[S1062] 1870 Federal Census Hunterdon Co. NJ, Washington, District of Columbia, page 65.

Aaron Sutton Jr.

M, b. circa 5 January 1798, d. 5 May 1857

Aaron Sutton Jr.|b. c 5 Jan 1798\nd. 5 May 1857|p31.htm#i926|Aaron Sutton|b. bt 1760 - 1770\nd. c 1844|p3.htm#i83|Mary Schuyler|b. bt 1760 - 1770\nd. b 1840|p17.htm#i495|John Sutton|b. c 1738\nd. 21 Nov 1822|p3.htm#i71|Elizabeth Aubel|b. c 1743\nd. 15 Nov 1825|p3.htm#i72|Philip Schuyler||p16.htm#i473|Ann Anderson||p16.htm#i474|

Aaron Sutton Jr. was born circa 5 January 1798 at Fairmount, Tewksbury Township, Hunterdon County, New Jersey.¹ He was the son of Aaron Sutton and Mary Schuyler. He married Catherine (Katie) Aubel, daughter of Jacob Aubel and Charity Pickel, on 15 April 1820 at Flemington, Raritan Township, Hunterdon County, New Jersey. He died on 5 May 1857 at Fairmount, Tewksbury Township, Hunterdon County, New Jersey, of apoplexy.^2,1 He was buried circa 8 May 1857 at Presbyterian Churchyard, Fairmount, Tewksbury Township, Hunterdon County, New Jersey.^2,1
Aaron Sutton Jr. appeared on the census of 1830 at Tewksbury Township, Hunterdon County, New Jersey.³ He appeared on the census of 1840 at Washington Township, Morris County, New Jersey.⁴ He appeared on the census of 13 August 1850 at Washington Township, Morris County, New Jersey.⁵

Children of Aaron Sutton Jr. and Catherine (Katie) Aubel

Julia Ann Sutton+ b. 1821
Mary Ann Sutton+ b. 1824
Eliza Jane Sutton+ b. 18 Jan 1828, d. 27 Jul 1896
Aaron S. Sutton+ b. 1 Mar 1832, d. 17 Feb 1909
Hannah Sutton+ b. 1835, d. c 1908
Laura E. O. Sutton b. 21 Nov 1838, d. 4 Nov 1842
Maria Sutton b. 1845
Elisabeth Sutton+ b. 1845, d. b 28 Apr 1886

Citations

[S427] "Genealogical Magazine of NJ", Hunterdon County Gravestones, Fairmount Presbyterian Church Yard, Tewksbury Township (copied 12 Oct 1936 by Genalogical Society of NJ members), Vol. 12, No. 3, Whole No. 49, July 1937, page 67.
[S983] NJ Deaths: Vital Stats 1848-67, Microfilm Vol. S, Reel 21, p. 373.
[S1059] 1830 Federal Census Hunterdon Co., NJ, Washington, District of Columbia, Microfilm roll M19-83, pg 445 (image 861). Census notes the following:

1 male - 50-60
1 female - under 5
2 females - 5-10
1 female - 30-40.
[S995] 1840 Federal Census Morris Co., NJ, Washington, District of Columbia, Microfilm M704-257, page 172A (image 51). Census notes the following:

1 male - 5-10
1 male - 30-40
1 female - under 5
1 female - 5-10
1 female - 10-15
1 female - 15-20
1 female - 30-40.
[S996] 1850 Federal Census Morris Co., NJ, Washington, District of Columbia, page 233.

Elizabeth Tiger

F, b. circa 1788, d. between 15 January 1873 and 15 February 1873

Elizabeth Tiger was born circa 1788 at New Jersey.¹ She married Peter Sutton, son of Aaron Sutton and Mary Schuyler, circa 1807 at New Jersey. She died between 15 January 1873 and 15 February 1873 at Cokesbury, Tewksbury Township, Hunterdon County, New Jersey, Our Home - A Monthly Magazine of Original Articles, Vol. 1, Apr 1873, No. 4, Pg 192. Edited by A. V. D. Honeyman, Somerville, N.J. Table of Deaths Jan 15, 1873-Feb 15, 1873.
Elizabeth Tiger appeared on the census of 12 August 1850 in the household of Peter Sutton at Tewksbury Township, Hunterdon County, New Jersey.² She appeared on the census of 30 July 1860 in the household of Peter Sutton at Clinton Township, Hunterdon County, New Jersey; Also noted with family is Peter Tiger, 16 (b. ca 1846).³ She appeared on the census of 24 August 1870 in the household of Peter Sutton at Clinton Township, Hunterdon County, New Jersey; Peter and Elizabeth are noted as unable to read or write.⁴

Children of Elizabeth Tiger and Peter Sutton

? Sutton b. bt 1810 - 1815
? Sutton b. bt 1815 - 1820
Catharine Sutton b. c 1823
Jeremiah C. Sutton b. c 1825, d. 17 Aug 1856
Malinda Sutton b. c 1827
? Sutton b. bt 1830 - 1835

Citations

[S975] 1850 Federal Census Hunterdon Co., NJ, Washington, District of Columbia, page 284A, line 26.
[S975] 1850 Federal Census Hunterdon Co., NJ, Washington, District of Columbia, Microfilm Roll: M432_453, page 284A, line 25.
[S988] 1860 Federal Census Hunterdon Co., NJ, unknown location, Microfilm M653-696, p. 696, line 30. Census notes: Peter is 71, Elizabeth 72, and Catherine 39.
[S1062] 1870 Federal Census Hunterdon Co. NJ, Washington, District of Columbia, page 65.

Catharine Sutton

F, b. circa 1823

Catharine Sutton|b. c 1823|p31.htm#i928|Peter Sutton|b. c 1789\nd. 10 Feb 1876|p31.htm#i925|Elizabeth Tiger|b. c 1788\nd. bt 15 Jan 1873 - 15 Feb 1873|p31.htm#i927|Aaron Sutton|b. bt 1760 - 1770\nd. c 1844|p3.htm#i83|Mary Schuyler|b. bt 1760 - 1770\nd. b 1840|p17.htm#i495|||||||

Catharine Sutton was born circa 1823 at Hunterdon County, New Jersey.¹ She was the daughter of Peter Sutton and Elizabeth Tiger.
Catharine Sutton appeared on the census of 12 August 1850 in the household of Peter Sutton at Tewksbury Township, Hunterdon County, New Jersey.² She appeared on the census of 30 July 1860 in the household of Peter Sutton at Clinton Township, Hunterdon County, New Jersey; Also noted with family is Peter Tiger, 16 (b. ca 1846).³

Citations

[S975] 1850 Federal Census Hunterdon Co., NJ, Washington, District of Columbia, page 284A, line 27.
[S975] 1850 Federal Census Hunterdon Co., NJ, Washington, District of Columbia, Microfilm Roll: M432_453, page 284A, line 25.
[S988] 1860 Federal Census Hunterdon Co., NJ, unknown location, Microfilm M653-696, p. 696, line 30. Census notes: Peter is 71, Elizabeth 72, and Catherine 39.

Jeremiah C. Sutton

M, b. circa 1825, d. 17 August 1856

Jeremiah C. Sutton|b. c 1825\nd. 17 Aug 1856|p31.htm#i929|Peter Sutton|b. c 1789\nd. 10 Feb 1876|p31.htm#i925|Elizabeth Tiger|b. c 1788\nd. bt 15 Jan 1873 - 15 Feb 1873|p31.htm#i927|Aaron Sutton|b. bt 1760 - 1770\nd. c 1844|p3.htm#i83|Mary Schuyler|b. bt 1760 - 1770\nd. b 1840|p17.htm#i495|||||||

Jeremiah C. Sutton was born circa 1825 at Tewksbury Township, Hunterdon County, New Jersey.¹ He was the son of Peter Sutton and Elizabeth Tiger. He married Catharine Parks on 15 March 1849 at Tewksbury Township, Hunterdon County, New Jersey.² He died on 17 August 1856 at Tewksbury Township, Hunterdon County, New Jersey, of diptheria.³
Jeremiah C. Sutton appeared on the census of 13 August 1850 at Tewksbury Township, Hunterdon County, New Jersey.⁴

Citations

[S975] 1850 Federal Census Hunterdon Co., NJ, Washington, District of Columbia, page 285B, line 22.
[S990] NJ Marriages: Vital Stats 1848-67, Microfilm Vol. S, Reel 21, p. 7a.
[S983] NJ Deaths: Vital Stats 1848-67, Microfilm Vol. S, Reel 21, p. 373.
[S975] 1850 Federal Census Hunterdon Co., NJ, Washington, District of Columbia, Microfilm Roll: M432_453, Page 285B, line 22.

Catharine Parks

F, b. circa 1832

Catharine Parks was born circa 1832 at New Jersey.¹ She married Jeremiah C. Sutton, son of Peter Sutton and Elizabeth Tiger, on 15 March 1849 at Tewksbury Township, Hunterdon County, New Jersey.²
Catharine Parks appeared on the census of 13 August 1850 in the household of Jeremiah C. Sutton at Tewksbury Township, Hunterdon County, New Jersey.³

Citations

[S975] 1850 Federal Census Hunterdon Co., NJ, Washington, District of Columbia, page 285B, line 23.
[S990] NJ Marriages: Vital Stats 1848-67, Microfilm Vol. S, Reel 21, p. 7a.
[S975] 1850 Federal Census Hunterdon Co., NJ, Washington, District of Columbia, Microfilm Roll: M432_453, Page 285B, line 22.

Catherine (Katie) Aubel

F, b. 24 April 1800, d. 29 July 1894

Catherine (Katie) Aubel|b. 24 Apr 1800\nd. 29 Jul 1894|p31.htm#i931|Jacob Aubel||p31.htm#i932|Charity Pickel||p31.htm#i933|||||||||||||

Catherine (Katie) Aubel was born on 24 April 1800 at New Jersey.¹ She was the daughter of Jacob Aubel and Charity Pickel. She married Aaron Sutton Jr., son of Aaron Sutton and Mary Schuyler, on 15 April 1820 at Flemington, Raritan Township, Hunterdon County, New Jersey. She died on 29 July 1894 at Fairmount, Tewksbury Township, Hunterdon County, New Jersey.¹ She was buried circa 1 August 1894 at First Presbyterian Churchyard, Fairmount, Tewksbury Township, Hunterdon County, New Jersey.^1,2
Catherine (Katie) Aubel appeared on the census of 1830 in the household of Aaron Sutton Jr. at Tewksbury Township, Hunterdon County, New Jersey.³ She appeared on the census of 13 August 1850 in the household of Aaron Sutton Jr. at Washington Township, Morris County, New Jersey.⁴ She appeared on the census of 8 August 1860 at Washington Township, Morris County, New Jersey.⁵ She appeared on the census of 18 August 1870 at Washington Township, Hunterdon County, New Jersey.⁶ She appeared on the census of 5 June 1880 in the household of George S. Hoffman at Washington Township, Morris County, New Jersey.⁷ She left a will on 28 April 1886 at Morris County, New Jersey.⁸

Children of Catherine (Katie) Aubel and Aaron Sutton Jr.

Julia Ann Sutton+ b. 1821
Mary Ann Sutton+ b. 1824
Eliza Jane Sutton+ b. 18 Jan 1828, d. 27 Jul 1896
Aaron S. Sutton+ b. 1 Mar 1832, d. 17 Feb 1909
Hannah Sutton+ b. 1835, d. c 1908
Laura E. O. Sutton b. 21 Nov 1838, d. 4 Nov 1842
Maria Sutton b. 1845
Elisabeth Sutton+ b. 1845, d. b 28 Apr 1886

Citations

[S427] "Genealogical Magazine of NJ", Hunterdon County Gravestones, Fairmount Presbyterian Church Yard, Tewksbury Township (copied 12 Oct 1936 by Genalogical Society of NJ members), Vol. 12, No. 3, Whole No. 49, July 1937, page 67.
[S1607] Find A Grave, online www.findagrave.com.
[S1059] 1830 Federal Census Hunterdon Co., NJ, Washington, District of Columbia, Microfilm roll M19-83, pg 445 (image 861). Census notes the following:

1 male - 50-60
1 female - under 5
2 females - 5-10
1 female - 30-40.
[S996] 1850 Federal Census Morris Co., NJ, Washington, District of Columbia, page 233.
[S979] 1860 Federal Census Morris Co., NJ, Washington, District of Columbia, Page 295, line 6.
[S1063] 1870 Federal Census, Morris Co., NJ, Washington, District of Columbia, p. 50.
[S1092] 1880 Federal Census, Morris Co., NJ, Washington, District of Columbia, Roll T9_793; Family History Film: 1254793; Page: 443.3000; Enumeration District: 133; Image: 0608; line 25, dwelling 81, family 88.
[S980] Catherine Aubel will #07597: proved 5 Nov 1894, Liber D2, Folio 31 HC. Will reads as follows:
Catharine Sutton of the township of Washington in the County of Morris and State of NJ. I bequeath unto my daughter Mary, wife of Richard Stevens and unto my daughter Julia Ann, wife of William Eick Five hundred dollard each.
I give and bequeath unto my daughter Jane, wife of George Fleming, five hundred dollars provided she has not deeded her interest in my estate to John C Welsh or to his heirs. In case she has so deeded away her interest in my estate then she is to receive nothing from my estate. I give and bequeath to my grandson Emery Hoffman and my granddaughter Laura Hoffman children of my daughter Elizabeth, deceased, late wife of George Hoffman - two hundren dollars each to be paid to them at the age of twenty one, or day of marriage which shall first happen but the said George Hoffman is not to receive anything from my estate.
I give and bequeath to my son Aaron S. Sutton, my daughter Hannah Schuyler wife of Philip Schuyler and to my granddaughter Mariah Buchanan wife of Elias Buchanan all the remaninder and residue of my estate both real and personal to be divided equally among them shara and share alike.
Lastly, I do hereby appoint my son Aaron S. Sutton executor of this my last will and testament. Dated Apr 28th 1886.

Jacob Aubel

He married Charity Pickel.

Child of Jacob Aubel and Charity Pickel

Catherine (Katie) Aubel+ b. 24 Apr 1800, d. 29 Jul 1894

Charity Pickel

She married Jacob Aubel.

Child of Charity Pickel and Jacob Aubel

Catherine (Katie) Aubel+ b. 24 Apr 1800, d. 29 Jul 1894

Julia Ann Sutton

F, b. 1821

Julia Ann Sutton|b. 1821|p31.htm#i934|Aaron Sutton Jr.|b. c 5 Jan 1798\nd. 5 May 1857|p31.htm#i926|Catherine (Katie) Aubel|b. 24 Apr 1800\nd. 29 Jul 1894|p31.htm#i931|Aaron Sutton|b. bt 1760 - 1770\nd. c 1844|p3.htm#i83|Mary Schuyler|b. bt 1760 - 1770\nd. b 1840|p17.htm#i495|Jacob Aubel||p31.htm#i932|Charity Pickel||p31.htm#i933|

Julia was born at New Jersey in 1821. She was the daughter of Aaron Sutton Jr. and Catherine (Katie) Aubel. She married William Eick at New Jersey on 22 January 1842.¹
Julia Ann Sutton appeared on the census of 1830 in the household of Aaron Sutton Jr. at Tewksbury Township, Hunterdon County, New Jersey.² She appeared on the census of 15 August 1850 in the household of William Eick at Tewksbury Township, Hunterdon County, New Jersey.³ She appeared on the census of 14 June 1880 in the household of William Eick at Tewksbury Township, Hunterdon County, New Jersey.⁴

Children of Julia Ann Sutton and William Eick

Mary C. Eick b. c 1843
Austin Eick b. c 1844
? Eick b. c 1846

Citations

[S65] Hiram E. Deats, Hunterdon Marriages, p. 90.
[S1059] 1830 Federal Census Hunterdon Co., NJ, Washington, District of Columbia, Microfilm roll M19-83, pg 445 (image 861). Census notes the following:

1 male - 50-60
1 female - under 5
2 females - 5-10
1 female - 30-40.
[S975] 1850 Federal Census Hunterdon Co., NJ, Washington, District of Columbia, page 288A.
[S1060] 1880 Federal Census, Hunterdon Co., NJ, Washington, District of Columbia, Microfilm reel T9-0787, SD 1, ED 88, page 27, line 10.

William Eick

M, b. circa 1819

William Eick was born circa 1819 at Hunterdon County, New Jersey. He married Julia Ann Sutton at New Jersey on 22 January 1842.¹
William Eick appeared on the census of 15 August 1850 at Tewksbury Township, Hunterdon County, New Jersey.² He appeared on the census of 14 June 1880 at Tewksbury Township, Hunterdon County, New Jersey.³

Children of William Eick and Julia Ann Sutton

Mary C. Eick b. c 1843
Austin Eick b. c 1844
? Eick b. c 1846

Citations

[S65] Hiram E. Deats, Hunterdon Marriages, p. 90.
[S975] 1850 Federal Census Hunterdon Co., NJ, Washington, District of Columbia, page 288A.
[S1060] 1880 Federal Census, Hunterdon Co., NJ, Washington, District of Columbia, Microfilm reel T9-0787, SD 1, ED 88, page 27, line 10.

Mary Ann Sutton

F, b. 1824

Mary Ann Sutton|b. 1824|p31.htm#i936|Aaron Sutton Jr.|b. c 5 Jan 1798\nd. 5 May 1857|p31.htm#i926|Catherine (Katie) Aubel|b. 24 Apr 1800\nd. 29 Jul 1894|p31.htm#i931|Aaron Sutton|b. bt 1760 - 1770\nd. c 1844|p3.htm#i83|Mary Schuyler|b. bt 1760 - 1770\nd. b 1840|p17.htm#i495|Jacob Aubel||p31.htm#i932|Charity Pickel||p31.htm#i933|

Mary was born at New Jersey in 1824. She was the daughter of Aaron Sutton Jr. and Catherine (Katie) Aubel. She married Richard Stephens at Washington Township, Morris County, New Jersey, on 16 November 1849.^1,2
Mary Ann Sutton appeared on the census of 1830 in the household of Aaron Sutton Jr. at Tewksbury Township, Hunterdon County, New Jersey.³ She appeared on the census of 11 September 1850 in the household of Richard Stephens at Washington Township, Morris County, New Jersey.⁴ She appeared on the census of 5 June 1880 in the household of Richard Stephens at Washington, Washington Township, Morris County, New Jersey; Also living with family is Richard Hazen, age 8, grandson.⁵

Children of Mary Ann Sutton and Richard Stephens

Emily Stephens b. c Aug 1850
Arthula Stephens b. c 1854
George H. Stephens b. c 1859

Citations

[S990] NJ Marriages: Vital Stats 1848-67, Microfilm Vol. Z, Reel 27, p. 20.
[S1372] First Presbyterian Church, 1st Presbyterian Church Records.
[S1059] 1830 Federal Census Hunterdon Co., NJ, Washington, District of Columbia, Microfilm roll M19-83, pg 445 (image 861). Census notes the following:

1 male - 50-60
1 female - under 5
2 females - 5-10
1 female - 30-40.
[S996] 1850 Federal Census Morris Co., NJ, Washington, District of Columbia, Roll: M432_459, Page: 251, line 30, dwelling 269, family 303.
[S1092] 1880 Federal Census, Morris Co., NJ, Washington, District of Columbia, Microfilm reel T9-0793, SD 1, ED 133, page 18, line 40.

Richard Stephens

M, b. circa 1825, d. before 1899

Richard Stephens|b. c 1825\nd. b 1899|p31.htm#i937||||Eve ?||p31.htm#i938|||||||||||||

Richard was born at New Jersey circa 1825. He was the son of Eve ? He married Mary Ann Sutton at Washington Township, Morris County, New Jersey, on 16 November 1849.^1,2 Richard died before 1899 at New Jersey.
Richard Stephens appeared on the census of 11 September 1850 at Washington Township, Morris County, New Jersey.³ He appeared on the census of 5 June 1880 at Washington, Washington Township, Morris County, New Jersey; Also living with family is Richard Hazen, age 8, grandson.⁴

Children of Richard Stephens and Mary Ann Sutton

Emily Stephens b. c Aug 1850
Arthula Stephens b. c 1854
George H. Stephens b. c 1859

Citations

[S990] NJ Marriages: Vital Stats 1848-67, Microfilm Vol. Z, Reel 27, p. 20.
[S1372] First Presbyterian Church, 1st Presbyterian Church Records.
[S996] 1850 Federal Census Morris Co., NJ, Washington, District of Columbia, Roll: M432_459, Page: 251, line 30, dwelling 269, family 303.
[S1092] 1880 Federal Census, Morris Co., NJ, Washington, District of Columbia, Microfilm reel T9-0793, SD 1, ED 133, page 18, line 40.

Eve ?

Child of Eve ?

Richard Stephens+ b. c 1825, d. b 1899

Eliza Jane Sutton

F, b. 18 January 1828, d. 27 July 1896

Eliza Jane Sutton|b. 18 Jan 1828\nd. 27 Jul 1896|p31.htm#i939|Aaron Sutton Jr.|b. c 5 Jan 1798\nd. 5 May 1857|p31.htm#i926|Catherine (Katie) Aubel|b. 24 Apr 1800\nd. 29 Jul 1894|p31.htm#i931|Aaron Sutton|b. bt 1760 - 1770\nd. c 1844|p3.htm#i83|Mary Schuyler|b. bt 1760 - 1770\nd. b 1840|p17.htm#i495|Jacob Aubel||p31.htm#i932|Charity Pickel||p31.htm#i933|

Eliza Jane Sutton was born on 18 January 1828 at New Jersey. She was the daughter of Aaron Sutton Jr. and Catherine (Katie) Aubel. She married George Fleming, son of Levi Fleming and Mary Beam, on 17 March 1857 at German Valley, Washington Township, Morris County, New Jersey.¹ Eliza died on 27 July 1896 at New Jersey at age 68. Her body was interred on 30 July 1896 at Fairmount, Tewksbury Township, Hunterdon County, New Jersey.
Eliza Jane Sutton appeared on the census of 1830 in the household of Aaron Sutton Jr. at Tewksbury Township, Hunterdon County, New Jersey.² She appeared on the census of 13 August 1850 in the household of Aaron Sutton Jr. at Washington Township, Morris County, New Jersey.³

Child of Eliza Jane Sutton and George Fleming

Deborah Ann Fleming b. 22 Sep 1861, d. 14 Jun 1936

Citations

[S990] NJ Marriages: Vital Stats 1848-67, Microfilm Vol. Z, Reel 27, p. 122.
[S1059] 1830 Federal Census Hunterdon Co., NJ, Washington, District of Columbia, Microfilm roll M19-83, pg 445 (image 861). Census notes the following:

1 male - 50-60
1 female - under 5
2 females - 5-10
1 female - 30-40.
[S996] 1850 Federal Census Morris Co., NJ, Washington, District of Columbia, page 233.

George Fleming

M, b. circa 1834

George Fleming|b. c 1834|p31.htm#i940|Levi Fleming|b. c 1800|p31.htm#i941|Mary Beam|b. c 1802|p31.htm#i942|||||||||||||

George Fleming was born circa 1834 at New Jersey. He was the son of Levi Fleming and Mary Beam. He married Eliza Jane Sutton, daughter of Aaron Sutton Jr. and Catherine (Katie) Aubel, on 17 March 1857 at German Valley, Washington Township, Morris County, New Jersey.¹
George Fleming appeared on the census of 24 July 1850 in the household of Levi Fleming at Tewksbury Township, Hunterdon County, New Jersey.² He appeared on the census of 8 August 1860 at Washington Township, Morris County, New Jersey.³

Child of George Fleming and Eliza Jane Sutton

Deborah Ann Fleming b. 22 Sep 1861, d. 14 Jun 1936

Citations

[S990] NJ Marriages: Vital Stats 1848-67, Microfilm Vol. Z, Reel 27, p. 122.
[S975] 1850 Federal Census Hunterdon Co., NJ, Washington, District of Columbia, Page 268A.
[S979] 1860 Federal Census Morris Co., NJ, Washington, District of Columbia, Page 295, line 10.

Levi Fleming

M, b. circa 1800

Levi Fleming was born circa 1800 at New Jersey.¹ He married Mary Beam circa 1820 at Hunterdon County, New Jersey.
Levi Fleming appeared on the census of 24 July 1850 at Tewksbury Township, Hunterdon County, New Jersey.² He appeared on the census of 1 June 1860 at Tewksbury Township, Hunterdon County, New Jersey; Also living with Levi's family is Harriet Fleming, age 3.³

Children of Levi Fleming and Mary Beam

William Fleming b. c 1821
Daniel Fleming b. c 1829
Mary E. Fleming b. c 1831
Nicklus Fleming b. c 1832
George Fleming+ b. c 1834
Hannah L. Fleming b. c 1836
Henry Fleming b. c 1838
Susen A. Fleming b. c 1840

Citations

[S975] 1850 Federal Census Hunterdon Co., NJ, Washington, District of Columbia, page 268A, line 7.
[S975] 1850 Federal Census Hunterdon Co., NJ, Washington, District of Columbia, Page 268A.
[S988] 1860 Federal Census Hunterdon Co., NJ, unknown location, page 16, image 16.

Mary Beam

F, b. circa 1802

Mary Beam was born circa 1802 at New Jersey.¹ She married Levi Fleming circa 1820 at Hunterdon County, New Jersey.
Mary Beam appeared on the census of 24 July 1850 in the household of Levi Fleming at Tewksbury Township, Hunterdon County, New Jersey.² She appeared on the census of 1 June 1860 in the household of Levi Fleming at Tewksbury Township, Hunterdon County, New Jersey; Also living with Levi's family is Harriet Fleming, age 3.³

Children of Mary Beam and Levi Fleming

William Fleming b. c 1821
Daniel Fleming b. c 1829
Mary E. Fleming b. c 1831
Nicklus Fleming b. c 1832
George Fleming+ b. c 1834
Hannah L. Fleming b. c 1836
Henry Fleming b. c 1838
Susen A. Fleming b. c 1840

Citations

[S975] 1850 Federal Census Hunterdon Co., NJ, Washington, District of Columbia, page 268A, line 8.
[S975] 1850 Federal Census Hunterdon Co., NJ, Washington, District of Columbia, Page 268A.
[S988] 1860 Federal Census Hunterdon Co., NJ, unknown location, page 16, image 16.

Aaron S. Sutton

M, b. 1 March 1832, d. 17 February 1909

Aaron S. Sutton|b. 1 Mar 1832\nd. 17 Feb 1909|p31.htm#i943|Aaron Sutton Jr.|b. c 5 Jan 1798\nd. 5 May 1857|p31.htm#i926|Catherine (Katie) Aubel|b. 24 Apr 1800\nd. 29 Jul 1894|p31.htm#i931|Aaron Sutton|b. bt 1760 - 1770\nd. c 1844|p3.htm#i83|Mary Schuyler|b. bt 1760 - 1770\nd. b 1840|p17.htm#i495|Jacob Aubel||p31.htm#i932|Charity Pickel||p31.htm#i933|

Aaron S. Sutton was born on 1 March 1832 at Washington Township, Morris County, New Jersey.¹ He was the son of Aaron Sutton Jr. and Catherine (Katie) Aubel. He married Sarah W. Anderson, daughter of Jacob Anderson and Hannah ?, on 6 February 1858 at Fairmount, Tewksbury Township, Hunterdon County, New Jersey.² He married Mary E. Apgar, daughter of Isaiah Apgar and Jane Walters, on 5 January 1876 at Dover, Morris County, New Jersey.³ He died on 17 February 1909 at Parker, Chester Township, Morris County, New Jersey, of acute pericarditis.⁴ His body was interred on 20 February 1909 at Fairmount, Tewksbury Township, Hunterdon County, New Jersey.⁴
Aaron was noted to be a blacksmith.
Aaron and Sarah lived in Washington Twp., Morris Co., NJ, in 1860. (Ref: 1860 NJ Census, microfilm M653, roll 703, p. 298, line 34.). He appeared on the census of 13 August 1850 in the household of Aaron Sutton Jr. at Washington Township, Morris County, New Jersey.⁵ He appeared on the census of 9 August 1860 at Washington Township, Morris County, New Jersey.⁶ He appeared on the census of 20 August 1870 at Washington Township, Morris County, New Jersey; Son is noted as Edgar vice Edward on census.⁷ As of 30 July 1876, Aaron S. Sutton was also known as Ora.⁸ He was a huskster in 1880.⁹ He appeared on the census of 5 June 1880 at Village of Unionville, Washington Township, Morris County, New Jersey.¹⁰ He appeared on the census of 1895 at Washington Township, Morris County, New Jersey.¹¹ He appeared on the census of 13 June 1900 at Washington Township, Morris County, New Jersey; Aaron and Mary were noted to have had 4 children with 3 still living.¹²

Children of Aaron S. Sutton and Sarah W. Anderson

unknown Sutton b. 18 Dec 1852
Austin E. Sutton+ b. 22 May 1859, d. 23 Jun 1922
Elias B. Sutton+ b. 30 Sep 1863, d. 22 Apr 1914
Dr. Edward Sutton b. 7 Jan 1867, d. 5 Jan 1910

Children of Aaron S. Sutton and Mary E. Apgar

Erastus W. Sutton b. 20 Jul 1876, d. 3 Sep 1954
Eli L. Sutton b. 16 Jan 1878, d. 13 Feb 1949
Unknown Sutton b. 1882, d. 1882
Roy Sutton+ b. 22 Sep 1884, d. 10 Jul 1947

Citations

[S275] John Hill, Morris Co. , Vol. 2.
[S990] NJ Marriages: Vital Stats 1848-67, Microfilm Vol. S, Reel 21, p. 124.
[S990] NJ Marriages: Marriages 1875-76, Microfilm Vol. BQ, Reel 70, p. 217.
[S279] Aaron S. Sutton, Aaron S. Sutton Death.
[S996] 1850 Federal Census Morris Co., NJ, Washington, District of Columbia, page 233.
[S979] 1860 Federal Census Morris Co., NJ, Washington, District of Columbia, Page 298, line 34.
[S1063] 1870 Federal Census, Morris Co., NJ, Washington, District of Columbia, p. 59.
[S986] NJ Births: 1848-78 VS, reel 98, Vol. CL, 1875-76, p247.
[S1092] 1880 Federal Census, Morris Co., NJ, Washington, District of Columbia.
[S1092] 1880 Federal Census, Morris Co., NJ, Washington, District of Columbia, Roll: T9_793; Family History Film: 1254793; Page: 444A; Enumeration District: 133; Image: 0610, line 4, dwelling 91, family 101.
[S1259] 1895 State Census, New Jersey, Microfilm, Roll: V227_95 Page: 14 Line: 23, dwelling 92, family 94.
[S1089] 1900 Federal Census, Morris Co., NJ, Washington, District of Columbia, SD 3, ED 83, Sheet 6B, line 67.

Hannah Sutton

F, b. 1835, d. circa 1908

Hannah Sutton|b. 1835\nd. c 1908|p31.htm#i944|Aaron Sutton Jr.|b. c 5 Jan 1798\nd. 5 May 1857|p31.htm#i926|Catherine (Katie) Aubel|b. 24 Apr 1800\nd. 29 Jul 1894|p31.htm#i931|Aaron Sutton|b. bt 1760 - 1770\nd. c 1844|p3.htm#i83|Mary Schuyler|b. bt 1760 - 1770\nd. b 1840|p17.htm#i495|Jacob Aubel||p31.htm#i932|Charity Pickel||p31.htm#i933|

Hannah was born at New Jersey in 1835. She was the daughter of Aaron Sutton Jr. and Catherine (Katie) Aubel. She married Philip Schuyler, son of Peter Schuyler and Barbary Apgar, on 9 February 1856 at Farmersville, Tewksbury Township, Hunterdon County, New Jersey.¹ She died circa 1908 at New Jersey. She was buried circa 1908 at Fairmount Cemetery, Fairmount, Tewksbury Township, Hunterdon County, New Jersey.²
Hannah Sutton appeared on the census of 13 August 1850 in the household of Aaron Sutton Jr. at Washington Township, Morris County, New Jersey.³ She appeared on the census of 9 August 1860 in the household of Philip Schuyler at Washington Township, Morris County, New Jersey.⁴

Children of Hannah Sutton and Philip Schuyler

Mary Amelia Schuyler b. 12 Feb 1857, d. b Aug 1860
Julia M. Schuyler b. c May 1860

Citations

[S990] NJ Marriages: Vital Stats 1848-67, Microfilm Vol. S, Reel 21, p. 100.
[S1607] Find A Grave, online www.findagrave.com.
[S996] 1850 Federal Census Morris Co., NJ, Washington, District of Columbia, page 233.
[S979] 1860 Federal Census Morris Co., NJ, Washington, District of Columbia, Page 297, line 20.

Philip Schuyler

M, b. 6 March 1831, d. circa 1901

Philip Schuyler|b. 6 Mar 1831\nd. c 1901|p31.htm#i945|Peter Schuyler|b. 22 Jun 1801\nd. 26 Mar 1859|p31.htm#i946|Barbary Apgar|b. c 22 Jun 1804\nd. 26 Oct 1880|p32.htm#i947|||||||||||||

Philip Schuyler was born on 6 March 1831 at Hunterdon County, New Jersey.¹ He was the son of Peter Schuyler and Barbary Apgar. He married Hannah Sutton, daughter of Aaron Sutton Jr. and Catherine (Katie) Aubel, on 9 February 1856 at Farmersville, Tewksbury Township, Hunterdon County, New Jersey.² He died circa 1901 at New Jersey. He was buried circa 1901 at Fairmount Cemetery, Fairmount, Tewksbury Township, Hunterdon County, New Jersey.³
Philip Schuyler appeared on the census of 9 August 1860 at Washington Township, Morris County, New Jersey.⁴

Children of Philip Schuyler and Hannah Sutton

Mary Amelia Schuyler b. 12 Feb 1857, d. b Aug 1860
Julia M. Schuyler b. c May 1860

Citations

[S63] Chambers, Hunterdon Co., NJ , p. 482.
[S990] NJ Marriages: Vital Stats 1848-67, Microfilm Vol. S, Reel 21, p. 100.
[S1607] Find A Grave, online www.findagrave.com.
[S979] 1860 Federal Census Morris Co., NJ, Washington, District of Columbia, Page 297, line 20.

Peter Schuyler

M, b. 22 June 1801, d. 26 March 1859

Peter Schuyler was born on 22 June 1801 at New Jersey.¹ He married Barbary Apgar on 7 July 1827 at Hunterdon County, New Jersey.² He died on 26 March 1859 at Tewksbury Township, Hunterdon County, New Jersey.¹ He was buried on 28 March 1859 at Presbyterian Churchyard, Fairmount, Tewksbury Township, Hunterdon County, New Jersey.¹

Children of Peter Schuyler and Barbary Apgar

Philip Schuyler+ b. 6 Mar 1831, d. c 1901
Mary Schuyler¹ b. c 11 Jan 1834, d. 16 Nov 1844

Citations

[S427] "Genealogical Magazine of NJ", Hunterdon County Gravestones, Fairmount Presbyterian Church Yard, Tewksbury Township (copied 12 Oct 1936 by Genalogical Society of NJ members), Vol. 12, No. 3, Whole No. 49, July 1937, page 66.
[S65] Hiram E. Deats, Hunterdon Marriages, p. 247 (Vol. 2, p. 316 of original source).